The midfielder curled the ball into the top corner of Everton’s net either side of half-time to put Sunderland 2-0 up at the Stadium of Light.
David Henen pulled a goal back in the 81st minute for Everton, who gave a PL2 debut to 16-year-old centre-back Ryan Astley, but the home side held on.
Everton’s hopes of retaining the D1 title were hit by the loss. They are fourth, seven points behind leaders Leicester City with a match in hand.
Sunderland: 6 Apr v Man Utd (A) PL2
Everton: 17 Mar v Brighton (A) PL Cup