Goalkeepers Alisson and Ederson could not be separated on the final day and will share the Castrol Golden Glove award.
The Brazilian pair went into Sunday’s matches with 20 clean sheets each, and neither was able to add to that total.
Alisson’s chances of a shutout were ended after three minutes against Wolverhampton Wanderers as Pedro Neto scored at close range, before Liverpool fought back to win 3-1.
That opened the door for Ederson to take the prize outright, but he was beaten twice against Aston Villa, before Manchester City also came from behind to triumph 3-2 and win the title.
It is only the second time the Golden Glove award has been shared, after Chelsea's Petr Cech and Arsenal's Wojciech Szczesny finished level in 2013/14.
Ederson becomes only the third man to claim the Golden Glove in three consecutive campaigns, after Pepe Reina for Liverpool and Joe Hart for Man City.
The winning total of 20 clean sheets is the joint third-highest since the award was created in 2004/05, matching Reina's tally from 2005/06.
Cech kept 24 shutouts in 2004/05, while Edwin van der Sar and Alisson managed 21 in 2008/09 and 2018/19 respectively.
See: Every Golden Glove winner
Also in this series
Part 1: Son and Salah win 2021/22 Golden Boot award
Part 3: Salah wins Playmaker of the Season award