Sheffield United's frontman scored in a 3-1 win over Tottenham Hotspur in Gameweek 32+.
He also produced a goal and an assist in a 3-0 victory over Chelsea in his previous appearance at Bramall Lane, recording his season-high haul of 11 points.
McBurnie can continue that run of returns against an Everton side that are without a clean sheet in their last five matches.
He is among four Differentials named by The Scout for Gameweek 37+ ahead of Saturday's 16:30 BST deadline.
The Scot can prove decisive against Everton as Sheff Utd look for a fifth successive home win.
McNeil's 61 successful crosses rank sixth among all players this season. The Canaries, meanwhile, have conceded 104 headed shots, the second-worst record in the league.
Tierney has produced an assist and a clean sheet across his last three away trips.
A recent move into the No 10 role for Spurs has boosted the midfielder's output.
Lo Celso has supplied an assist against both Everton and Newcastle United in the last four Gameweeks.