Feature

Best moment? Standout signing? Pundits pick their 2024/25 award winners

4 Jun 2025
PL_PUNDITS_AWARDS

Shay Given, Michael Owen, Karen Carney and other former players pick their best XI, match, goal, assist, overachievers and more

Related Articles
REVEALED: 2024/25 Fan Team of the Season
Best 50 photos of the 2024/25 Premier League season
One stat that sums up each club’s 2024/25 season

The 2024/25 Premier League season was another memorable campaign, with glorious goals, sensational saves, outrageous assists and memorable matches aplenty. Here, our pundits pick their standout player, manager, moment and more from the season.

Best player

Darren Bent: Mohamed Salah. His performances and his numbers have been a level above.

Matt Holland: Salah. It’s hard to look past the man with the most goals and the most assists in the Premier League this season.

Tim Sherwood: Salah for his goals, assists and incredible consistency.

Karen Carney, Don Hutchison, Glenn Murray, Leon Osman, Michael Owen, Shaun Wright-Phillips: Salah.

Shay Given: Virgil van Dijk.

Unfortunately, this video is no longer available. Please try another video.

Best manager

Darren Bent: Arne Slot - coming in to the Premier League and winning the title in your first season is incredible.

Matt Holland: Slot. He had the unenviable task of following Jurgen Klopp at Anfield with minimal transfer activity and masterminded a title with four games to spare.

Tim Sherwood: Slot, for following the legend Klopp and winning the Premier League in his first season.

Karen Carney, Don Hutchison, Glenn Murray, Michael Owen, Shaun Wright-Phillips: Slot.

Shay Given: Eddie Howe.

Leon Osman: Nuno Espirito Santo.

Best goal

Darren Bent: Omar Marmoush against AFC Bournemouth. We just don't see people shoot like that anymore from 30 yards. It had dip, bend, swerve... the lot.

Tim Sherwood: Marmoush v Bournemouth. An important goal to open the scoring.

Unfortunately, this video is no longer available. Please try another video.

Karen Carney: Harry Wilson v Brentford.

Glenn Murray: Alexander Isak v Liverpool at St James' Park.

Matt Holland: Kaoru Mitoma v Chelsea - you won’t see a better first touch! The second, third and fourth touches weren’t bad either!

Leon Osman: Mitoma against Chelsea - the touch and finish!

Unfortunately, this video is no longer available. Please try another video.

Don Hutchison, Michael Owen, Shaun Wright-Phillips: Mitoma.

Shay Given: Jean-Philippe Mateta v Arsenal.

Pundits best goal (2)

Click here to zoom in on image

Best save

Matt Holland: Emiliano Martinez at Nottingham Forest - I was commentating on the game and couldn’t believe it didn’t go in! Sensational reflexes and it gets better every time you see it.

Shay Given, Don Hutchison, Michael Owen: Martinez v Forest.

Unfortunately, this video is no longer available. Please try another video.

Leon Osman: Andre Onana for Manchester United at Crystal Palace or Jordan Pickford's against West Ham.

Tim Sherwood: David Raya for Arsenal from Ollie Watkins at Aston Villa.

Best assist

Matt Holland: Milos Kerkez for Marcus Tavernier. There may have been better, but from memory, this was the best cross I have seen all season. An early delivery provided a deep, inch-perfect cross.

Shay Given: Ryan Gravenberch for Salah.

Tim Sherwood: Reece James for Marc Cucurella v Man Utd.

Michael Owen: Raul Jimenez's backheel for Andreas Pereira against Manchester City.

Leon Osman, Don Hutchison: Jimenez.

Pundits best assist (1)

Click here to zoom in on image

Favourite moment 

Karen Carney: Everton fans and the nice scenes of them saying goodbye to Goodison Park at their last home game. It was emotional but it showed what it means to the fans.

Glenn Murray: James Tarkowski’s last-gasp equaliser for Everton v Liverpool, in the last men's Merseyside derby at Goodison Park.

Leon Osman: Tarkowski's goal in the Merseyside derby.

Shaun Wright-Phillips: Palace's FA Cup final win.

Michael Owen: Liverpool's celebrations after the game at Anfield against Spurs.

Don Hutchison: Liverpool players in front of The Kop singing "You'll Never Walk Alone" when they won the league.

Darren Bent: Jamie Vardy scoring his 200th goal in his 500th appearance. A true legend of the Premier League.

Tim Sherwood: Vardy's 200th goal in his 500th game.

Matt Holland: It may not have gone to plan, but to see Ipswich Town back in the Premier League after a 22-year absence was a personal standout. For something different, Justin Kluivert's hat-trick of penalties for AFC Bournemouth at Wolves.

Shay Given: Newcastle United winning the EFL Cup.

Best signing

Matt Holland: Dean Huijsen. It took him a while to break into Bournemouth's side, but he was irreplaceable when he eventually did.

Karen Carney, Shay Given, Glenn Murray: Huijsen.

Tim Sherwood: Nikola Milenkovic. A solid defender for Forest and great value.

Michael Owen: Milenkovic.

Don Hutchison: Elliot Anderson.

Leon Osman: Villa's Marco Asensio - it showed the intent and the draw of the club.

Shaun Wright-Phillips: Marmoush.

Pundits best signing (1)

Click here to zoom in on image

Most improved player

Matt Holland: Liverpool looked determined to sign a holding midfielder last summer. That didn’t materialise and Gravenberch filled that position brilliantly.

Shay Given, Don Hutchison: Gravenberch.

Karen Carney: Mikkel Damsgaard and Gravenberch.

Unfortunately, this video is no longer available. Please try another video.

Glenn Murray: Jacob Murphy.

Shaun Wright-Phillips:
Nicolas Jackson.

Tim Sherwood: Chris Wood. The season of his life.

Michael Owen: Antoine Semenyo.

Pundits most improved player (1)

Click here to zoom in on image

Biggest overachievers

Matt Holland: Forest. Most people had them to be in the conversation for relegation and yet against the odds they have qualified for Europe!

Darren Bent, Don Hutchison, Glenn Murray, Leon Osman, Michael Owen, Tim Sherwood, Shaun Wright-Phillips: Forest.

Unfortunately, this video is no longer available. Please try another video.

Best match

Karen Carney: All of them.

Shay Given: Brentford 5-3 Wolves.

Matt Holland: Spurs 3-6 Liverpool. A crazy game that Liverpool dominated, looking like champions-elect.

Don Hutchison: Newcastle 3-3 Liverpool.

Glenn Murray: Brighton 3-2 Spurs.

Leon Osman: Everton 2-2 Liverpool.

Michael Owen: Not sure. Too many to choose from!

Tim Sherwood: Spurs 3-4 Chelsea.

Shaun Wright-Phillips: Newcastle in the EFL Cup final.

Pundits best match (1)

Click here to zoom in on image

Best XI
Darren Bent
1-DBENT-XI
Karen Carney
1-KAREN-CARNEY-XI
Shay Given
1-SHAY-GIVEN-XI
Matt Holland
1-MATT-HOLLAND-XI
Don Hutchison
1-DON-HUTCH-XI
Glenn Murray
1-MURRAY-XI
Leon Osman
1-LEON-OSMAN-XI
Michael Owen
1-OWEN-XI-V2
Tim Sherwood
1-SHERWOOD-XI
Shaun Wright-Phillips
1-SWP-XI

Latest Videos

More Videos

Unfortunately, this video is no longer available. Please try another video.

04 Jun 2025

Liam Delap joins Chelsea: Watch all his Premier League goals

The 22-year-old striker has completed a transfer from Ipswich to Chelsea, after an impressive 2024/25 season in the Premier League

Your entry has been submitted successfully.

You have already submitted an entry. Please check your email for further information.

Your entry has been submitted successfully.

Create a Premier League account

Continue

You are logged in as

Fill in your details to submit your entry