Premier League Logo
Talking Tactics

Season trends: Managers' changes making the difference

Adrian Clarke 4 Jun 2020
Man City midfielder Phil Foden and manager Pep Guardiola

Adrian Clarke looks at how Man City's Pep Guardiola and other coaches are having an impact with their substitutions

Adrian Clarke looks at tactical trends of the 2019/20 season so far. 

Early substitutions 

In-game management plays a critical part in every team’s season 

Adapting to new scenarios, changing your tactical approach when necessary and making the right substitutions at the correct time all form part of a manager or head coach's brief.  

In this regard some are more decisive than others.  

Never afraid to alter the shape, Brighton & Hove Albion’s Graham Potter has made the most half-time substitutions.  

Those tweaks have often worked out well for the Seagulls. They would rank 10th in the division for results only in the second half of matches, which would surpass their current position of 15th in the table.  

AFC Bournemouth’s Eddie Howe and former West Ham United manager Manuel Pellegrini have also made frequent changes at the interval, but with less success.  

In fact, the Cherries have the worst record after the break of all 20 Premier League teams.  

Most half-time subs 2019/20
Manager Total
Graham Potter  7
Manuel Pellegrini  6
Eddie Howe 6

Injuries can of course prompt substitutions but the bulk of changes tend to be of a tactical nature.  

Every manager has their own outlook but certain coaches do not flinch if a reshuffle is needed.  

With a wealth of talent sitting on his bench, it is perhaps no surprise that Pep Guardiola leads the way for most changes during the first 15 minutes of the second half.  

If he is not happy he will take action.  

Most subs 46th to 59th minute 
Manager Total
Pep Guardiola 10
Chris Wilder 9
Dean Smith 9
Nuno Espirito Santo 9

Premier League newcomers Chris Wilder and Dean Smith are like-minded, as is Wolverhampton Wanderers head coach Nuno Espirito Santo 

Of those three teams, Wolves have enjoyed the biggest uplift in performance.  

They have a disappointing goal difference of minus-11 in the first half of matches, but after the interval they are a different animal.  

Helped on occasion by smart changes from Nuno, they boast a marvellous +18 goal difference from the 46th minute onwards.  

The game-changers 

So, which managers impact matches most often via a clever substitution? 

Brendan Rodgers is top of the pile after 29 matches of the campaign.  

The Leicester City manager has a settled starting XI but with excellent back-up players who are hungry to make a good impression, he has the potential to transform matches.

Seven assists and five goals have stemmed from substitutes brought on by Rodgers 

Leicester have also won three and drawn three of the 11 matches where they have trailed 1-0.  

Studying the top two in the table below, it is worth noting that Manchester City, with 37, and Leicester, with 36, are the top scorers in the second half of matches. 

Whose subs have made biggest impact?
Manager Subs used Goals Assists Goal contributions
Brendan Rodgers 78 5 7 12
Pep Guardiola 79 6 3 9
Sean Dyche 58 5 3 8
Chris Wilder 78 6 2 8
Graham Potter 85 5 2 7

Guardiola’s former assistant Mikel Arteta seems to have picked up the art of intuitive second-half changes from his mentor.  

In only 10 matches in charge of Arsenal his substitutes have scored two goals and supplied two assists.  

The Spaniard’s success rate is therefore very close to that of Rodgers.  

Managers need strength in depth to be able to alter the course of matches, but their in-game decision-making also impacts a lot of results.  

See: Adrian Clarke's season trends

Latest News

More News: Latest News

Latest Videos

More Videos: Latest Videos

Cookies on premierleague.com

The Premier League website employs cookies to make our website work and improve your user experience. Essential cookies are required for the operation of our website. You may disable these but this may affect website functionality. Non-essential cookies help us improve the functionality of our website by collecting information and reporting on your use of the website as well as improving your user experience. You can manage your cookie settings and switch off non-essential cookies via the “Manage Settings” below.

Manage Settings
I accept cookies from this site