Friday 31 August 2012
As the latest transfer window comes to a close, we seek to give the background to the system's origins and how it works.
When did the present transfer window system begin?
The present system was introduced for the 2002/3 season.
Why was it introduced?
Windows were introduced as part of a compromise agreement with the European Commission about how the whole transfer system worked and how it could best preserve contractual stability for both the player and the club while allowing movement at prescribed times during the year – the summer and winter transfer windows in effect.
The alternative was to bring football in line with most other industries where contracts were not enforceable or liable for appropriate compensation, i.e. notice periods being served and players moving at will. The football authorities across Europe felt this would fatally undermine the footballing economy and remove the incentive for clubs to invest in developing players.
What was life like for Premier League clubs before the transfer window?
Players could be traded throughout the season up until March 31. Beyond that it was felt that allowing transfers could undermine the integrity of competitions.
For example, a team going for the title might suddenly acquire players from a club with nothing to play for at the end of the season on short-term contracts, not something that was really in the spirit of a season-long league competition. But the rest of the season you could lose, or gain, a player at point.
How does having a transfer window help the clubs?
UEFA had transfer windows for their club competitions before they were introduced domestically so some clubs were used to operating within them. The main benefits are that it enables clubs and managers to plan for a set period of time, knowing the players they have at their disposal.
It also gives the opportunity for younger players to play if there are injuries or drops in form from established first-team members, whereas before the temptation would always be to go and buy a replacement.
It is good for fans as well. Knowing that your squad is settled for at least two chunks of the season means they can invest in those players, emotionally and with that other modern phenomenon: names on the back of shirts.
Several managers have suggested that the transfer window should end when the Barclays Premier League season starts. Why is that not the case?
It is something that, in an ideal world, the Premier League would like to see. The problem is we operate in a European, and often a global market, so while they might be happy that the window closed in England they would be less happy to see their Spanish, German or Italian rivals continue to trade and pursue their transfer targets.
Until it was accepted by the major European football leagues there would be little chance of it being introduced by the Premier League, though it is something that will be raised at European Club Association and European Professional Football League’s level. (Click here for the transfer windows in Europe)
Will there be a change in the transfer window dates in the near future?
It is extremely doubtful. Despite some of the criticism of its effect on the game, it works pretty effectively in what it sets out to do: to preserve contractual stability while permitting opportunities for movement and allow clubs to plan for the coming season.
What are the exact dates of the transfer windows? Why those dates?
The summer window officially runs from July 1-August 31, but English clubs can strike deals from June because the season has ended. The winter window starts from January 1 to the end of the month.
The summer date was adopted because it mirrored the UEFA deadline for registration of players for its competitions.
Who decides when the transfer window closes? Why is it at 11pm this summer?
Each league and association has some limited scope for setting the deadline, but ultimately FIFA sets the parameters and if a competition fell too far outside of them, they would leave themselves open to sanction.
The window in England normally closes at 11pm on the final day of each of the summer and winter periods – August 31 and January 31 respectively. If this is a weekend or a bank holiday, there is flexibility to go into the next working day, which is normally until 5pm
Why are there different transfer window dates across Europe?
Nineteen of the 53 European countries, the majority of them the major footballing nations, will close at the same time. There are various factors as to why some will allow a greater degree of flexibility, but mainly to do with working practices, weekends, holidays and the like.The vast majority of business is concluded within the main window.